11.19 | data centers for the people

For all you can say about American paranoia during the last Cold War, at least some of that energy went toward real scientific progress. We put a man on the moon ahead of our rival then. These days, it’s like we’re all in on McCarthy, but a hard no on NASA.

Share
11.19 | data centers for the people
Photo by Winston Chen / Unsplash

✉️ letter #82

“If American data centers weren't just massive extraction projects colonizing the land of their own people, wouldn't communities here be a little less angry?”

Here in the States, the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act (BAAJA) is currently being rammed through Congress for a vote before the Thanksgiving recess. Proponents frame BAAJA as a necessary step to maintain U.S. AI supremacy, but as environmental advocates like Earth Justice and Native organizations like National Congress of Indians have pointed out, the bill is practically designed to fast-track “dirty” data center build-outs.

In streamlining the permitting process, it limits judicial reviews and paves the way for utilities to fire up old natural gas peaker plants to meet the insatiable energy demands these facilities require. It’s wild that this has such a good chance fo passing, considering Americans literally just showed their immense disapproval for our disorganized and damaging AI infrastructure build out with votes.

Yet in a move the U.S. government has been repeating since climate change became a thing, they are insisting the environmental impact (and what the public thinks) doesnt’ matter because we have got to stay competitive with China. Worse, some (OpenAI and several politicians) have suggested that we can’t even trust the people protesting, that local opposition are being bolstered by influence operations by the Chinese state. 


🎼 the soundtrack | take me to beijing (一起回北京) - chinese american bear


I tried to outline why this is kind of a ridiculous line of thinking in a short video this week (I think I’m getting better at these!) but you can really only fit so many points into three minutes. There is a lot more to unpack.

Most front-of-mind is the sheer irony of blaming foreign actors to delegitimize organic grassroots movements – a move I had, up to this point, more regularly associated with China itself. 

As if China has ever been good at producing globally-focused propaganda. Despite a booming microdrama industry, Beijing still refuses to court that talent for making anything anyone would actually watch. It seems to do much better in honeypotting, iykyk.

And as if Americans couldn’t possibly be legitimately angry that their water is getting dirtier, their electricity bills are rising, and that noise and carcinogenic pollution is on their doorsteps with no foreseeable benefit to them. The American AI boom is all downsides for regular American people and I just can’t fathom the level of delulu required to not immediately see that.

As I talk about in the video, it’s a completely different equation for Chinese citizens. Critics are quick to point out that China’s Eastern Data, Western Computing (东数西算) strategy isn’t working as smoothly as advertised, with build outs looking less like the frontier of AI operations and more like “ghost” data centers. That’s a fair critique – though it’s worth remembering that China’s infamous “ghost” cities eventually got filled (and DeepSeek has already begun a massive 1-gigawatt pivot to Ulanqab). More importantly, the policy shows how China is incorporating the AI boom in lockstep with a plan to keep the nation competitive, not just five giant corporations. 

It’s wild to watch America abandon the exact things that actually made us an innovation superpower—slashing STEM research grants, making it harder for global talent to come here, and ignoring our own copyright laws for tech’s remix machines—while insisting that deregulating dirty data centers is the only way to beat China. 

For all you can say about American paranoia during the last Cold War, at least some of that energy went toward real scientific progress. We put a man on the moon ahead of our rival then. These days, it’s like we’re all in on McCarthy, but a hard no on NASA.


🪢related threads


✨enjoying: a piece of pop culture fun

Part of the reason I wanted to continue making videos was to sidestep out of this AI apocalypse and the attention economy, and part of the inspiration to try and find an aesthetic that felt true to myself came from a medium-sized Youtube channel the algorithm actually got right when it delivered it unto me.

Mia's Digital Diary manages to blend self-help-ish introspection with a truly breathtaking creative style. While I'm personally not crafty enough to imitate the way she journals or collages things and thoughts together, I truly appreciate how just watching her do it somehow sparks something within myself – a willingness to experiment and create.


🗨️a final quote

Never does nature say one thing and wisdom another
-- Juvenal

Stalk me on Social Media

Instagram | TikTok | LinkedIN | Twitter | Goodreads | Spotify